The Anchor Fellowship is home to both Protestant and Catholic backgrounds, people of many different denominations as well as people who have no history with the Church. They feel this is a great strength of their fellowship, though they understand that their diversity presents unique challenges. One of their core values is living life together, learning how to become more and more like Jesus while developing deep and meaningful relationships with brothers and sisters in Christ. Their commitment to living life together is not based on having the same theological points of view, but that it is redemption which holds us together. Their approach is reflected in the old church motto, "In Essentials, Unity; in Non-Essentials, Liberty; in All Things, Love."